<?xml version='1.0' encoding='utf-8'?>
<!DOCTYPE rfc [
  <!ENTITY nbsp    "&#160;">
  <!ENTITY zwsp   "&#8203;">
  <!ENTITY nbhy   "&#8209;">
  <!ENTITY wj     "&#8288;">
]>
<?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="rfc2629.xslt" ?>
<!-- generated by https://github.com/cabo/kramdown-rfc version 1.7.29 (Ruby 3.2.3) -->
<rfc xmlns:xi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XInclude" ipr="trust200902" docName="draft-ietf-green-use-cases-00" category="info" consensus="true" submissionType="IETF" tocInclude="true" sortRefs="true" symRefs="true" version="3">
  <!-- xml2rfc v2v3 conversion 3.31.0 -->
  <front>
    <title abbrev="Use Cases for Energy Efficiency">Use Cases for Energy Efficiency Management</title>
    <seriesInfo name="Internet-Draft" value="draft-ietf-green-use-cases-00"/>
    <author fullname="Emile Stephan">
      <organization>Orange</organization>
      <address>
        <email>emile.stephan@orange.com</email>
      </address>
    </author>
    <author fullname="Marisol Palmero">
      <organization>Individual</organization>
      <address>
        <email>marisol.ietf@gmail.com</email>
      </address>
    </author>
    <author fullname="Benoit Claise">
      <organization>Huawei</organization>
      <address>
        <email>benoit.claise@huawei.com</email>
      </address>
    </author>
    <author fullname="Qin Wu">
      <organization>Huawei</organization>
      <address>
        <email>bill.wu@huawei.com</email>
      </address>
    </author>
    <author fullname="Luis M. Contreras">
      <organization>Telefonica</organization>
      <address>
        <email>luismiguel.contrerasmurillo@telefonica.com</email>
      </address>
    </author>
    <author fullname="Carlos J. Bernardos">
      <organization>Universidad Carlos III de Madrid</organization>
      <address>
        <email>cjbc@it.uc3m.es</email>
      </address>
    </author>
    <date year="2025" month="November" day="19"/>
    <area>Operations and Management</area>
    <workgroup>Getting Ready for Energy-Efficient Networking</workgroup>
    <keyword>Sustainability, Ressources</keyword>
    <abstract>
      <?line 81?>

<t>This document groups use cases for Energy efficiency Management of network devices.</t>
      <t>Discussion Venues</t>
      <t>Source of this draft and an issue tracker can be found at https://github.com/emile22/draft-ietf-green-use-cases</t>
    </abstract>
    <note removeInRFC="true">
      <name>About This Document</name>
      <t>
        The latest revision of this draft can be found at <eref target="https://emile22.github.io/draft-ietf-green-use-cases/draft-ietf-green-use-cases.html"/>.
        Status information for this document may be found at <eref target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-green-use-cases/"/>.
      </t>
      <t>
        Discussion of this document takes place on the
        Getting Ready for Energy-Efficient Networking Working Group mailing list (<eref target="mailto:green@ietf.org"/>),
        which is archived at <eref target="https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/green/"/>.
        Subscribe at <eref target="https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/green/"/>.
      </t>
      <t>Source for this draft and an issue tracker can be found at
        <eref target="https://github.com/emile22/draft-ietf-green-use-cases"/>.</t>
    </note>
  </front>
  <middle>
    <?line 89?>

<section anchor="introduction">
      <name>Introduction</name>
      <t>This document groups use cases collected from operators and from discussions since the GREEN WG preparations.</t>
      <t>It provides a set of use cases for Energy efficiency Management of network devices. The scope is devices like switches, routers, servers and storage devices having an IP address providing a management interface. It includes their built-in components that receive and provide electrical energy.</t>
      <t>In annex we recall the framework where the use cases can be put in situation.</t>
    </section>
    <section anchor="use-cases">
      <name>Use Cases</name>
      <t>This section describes a number of relevant use cases with the purpose of elicit requirements for Energy Efficiency Management.
This is a work in progress and additional use cases will be documented in next versions of this document. Use cases which are not tied enough to the current GREEN chater will be moved to the GREEN WG wiki pages or to other WGs or RGs.</t>
      <section anchor="incremental-use-case">
        <name>Incremental Application of the GREEN Framework</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>This section describes an incremental example <xref target="legacy-path"/> of usage showing how a product, a service and a network can use the framework in different settings.</t>
          <t>This use case is the less trendy of all the use cases by far as its ambitious is limited to migration and coexistence, as usual. Nevertheless from a telco perspective, it is the centrality for 2 main reasons:</t>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>to start immediatly the move to energy efficiency using legacy devices;</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>to account the gain of energy efficiency during incremental deployment of energy efficient network components;</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <t>Legacy routers, equipped with traditional Ethernet ports and optical interfaces will continue to operate within the network. As part of broader sustainability and energy efficiency goals, there is interest in exploring the incremental integration of such devices into energy efficiency framework deployments.</t>
          <t>Two directions are considered:</t>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Improving energy efficiency of legacy devices through targeted upgrades such as replacing line cards, optimizing firmware behavior, or reconfiguring interface usage based on operational demand.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Including legacy devices in early phases of energy-aware system deployment, ensuring that improvements are not limited only to new hardware generations.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <t>Legacy devices can still contribute to reducing overall power consumption and lowering resource usage and associated environmental impact. Supporting these incremental improvements helps bridge the gap between existing infrastructure and modern energy-aware network strategies.</t>
          <t>Device moving gradually to GREEN energy efficiency supports:</t>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>step 1 "baseline" : establishing a reference point of typical energy usage, which is crucial for identifying inefficiencies and measuring improvements over time.
At this step the controler use only the (c) part of the framework. It is collected from the datasheet.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <t>By establishing a baseline and using benchmarking, you can determine if your networking equipment is performing normally or if it is "off" from expected performance, guiding you in making necessary improvements.</t>
          <t>The initial measurement of your networking equipment's energy efficiency and performance, aka Baselining, needs to be in coordination with the vendor specifications and industry standards to understand what is considered normal or optimal performance.
example:
Baseline: Your switches operate at 5 Gbps per watt.
Benchmarking: Vendor specification is 8 Gbps per watt; industry standard is 10 Gbps per watt.
Action: Implement energy-saving measures and upgrades.
Tracking: Measure again to see if efficiency improves towards 8-10 Gbps per watt.</t>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>step 2 "component":  part of the device hw or sw migrated to support GREEN framework elements.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>step 3 "device controleur"</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>step 4 "network level"</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>This use case demonstrates how Energy Efficiency can be incrementally applied and measured in legacy networks.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Ensures that energy efficiency can be deployed, operated and measured per components, without waiting for full infrastructure upgrades.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Baseline Measurement: Ability to establish reference energy usage per device (from datasheets or monitoring).</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Component-Level Upgradability: Support partial migration of device subsystems to GREEN-aware models.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Legacy Compatibility: Ensure the framework can include legacy equipment alongside GREEN-enabled devices.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Energy Saving Validation: Mechanisms to measure and verify actual energy savings over time.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Protection from Overuse: Avoid frequent power cycling that may damage sensitive components like lasers or connectors.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="selective-reduction-of-energy-consumption-in-network-parts-proportional-to-traffic-levels">
        <name>Selective reduction of energy consumption in network parts proportional to traffic levels</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-1">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>Traffic levels in a network follow patterns reflecting the behavior of consumers. Those patterns show periodicity in the terms of the traffic delivered, that can range from daily (from 00:00 to 23:59) to seasonal (e.g., winter to summer), showing peaks and valleys that could be exploited to reduce the consumption of energy in the network proportionally, in case the underlying network elements incorporate such capabilities. The reduction of energy consumption could be performed by leveraging on sleep modes in components up to more extreme actions such as switching off network components or modules. Such decisions are expected to no impact on the service delivered to customers, and could be accompanied by traffic relocation and / or concentration in the network.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-1">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>This use case fits within the GREEN WG's objectives by emphasizing energy-aware operational adjustments across network infrastructure that optimize energy use based on traffic loads and the intelligent activation/deactivation of resources.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-1">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Reducing energy usage during during low-demand periods can lower operational costs and carbon emissions while also prolonging equipment lifespan.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-1">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Support for device and component-level sleep, standby, and hibernation modes.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Component-level control (e.g., ports, modules).</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="reporting-on-lifecycle-management">
        <name>Reporting on Lifecycle Management</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-2">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>Lifecycle information related to manufacturing energy costs, transport,
   recyclability, and end-of-life disposal impacts is part of what is
   called "embedded carbon." This information is considered to be an
   estimated value, which might not be implemented today in the network
   devices. It might be part of the vendor information, and to be collected
   from datasheets or databases. In accordance with ISO 14040/44, this
   information should be considered as part of the sustainable strategy
   related to energy efficiency. Also, refer to the ecodesign framework
   [(EU) 2024/1781] published in June by the European Commission.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="carbon-reporting">
          <name>Carbon Reporting</name>
          <t>To report on carbon equivalents for global reporting, it is important
   to correlate the location where the specific entity/network element
   is operating with the corresponding carbon factor. Refer to the world
   emission factor from the International Energy Agency (IEA), electricity
   maps applications that reflect the carbon intensity of the electricity
   consumed, etc.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="energy-mix">
          <name>Energy Mix</name>
          <t>Energy efficiency is not limited to reducing the energy consumption, it is common to include carbon free, solar energy, wind energy, cogeneration in the efficiency.</t>
          <t>The type of the sources of energy of the power is one criteria of efficiency.</t>
          <t>There are other dimensions that must visible: As many telecom locations include battery or additionnally several backups levels (as example battery, standby generator ...) there is a requirement to known exactly when a backup power is in used and which one is.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-2">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>Capture lifecycle energy data and integrate it with operational metrics.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-2">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Considering energy from production to disposal supports the broader goal of reducing total environmental impact.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-2">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Awareness of backup systems (e.g., batteries, generators).</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Data ingestion from vendor databases or datasheets.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="real-time-energy-metering-of-virtualised-or-cloud-native-network-functions">
        <name>Real-time Energy Metering of Virtualised or Cloud-native Network Functions</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-3">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>Cloud-native and virtualized functions require precise real-time energy measurements to manage their dynamic workloads and infrastructure efficiently.
Effective metering of virtualized network infrastructure is critical for the efficient management and operation of next-generation mobile networks <xref target="GREEN_NGNM"/>.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-3">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>Meter and manage energy at both hardware and software layers.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-3">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Granular and real-time insights into energy use enable optimization of virtualized workloads, leading to reduced energy footprints.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-3">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <t>// TODO.</t>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="indirect-energy-monitoring-and-control">
        <name>Indirect Energy Monitoring and control</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-4">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>There are cases where Energy Management for some devices need to report on other entities. There are two major
   reasons for this.</t>
          <t>o  For monitoring energy consumption of a particular entity, it is not always sufficient to
      communicate only with that entity.  When the entity has no
      instrumentation for determining power, it might still be possible
      to obtain power values for the entity via communication with other
      entities in its power distribution tree.  A simple example of this
      would be the retrieval of power values from a power meter at the
      power line into the entity.  A Power Distribution Unit (PDU) and a
      Power over Ethernet (PoE) switch are common examples.  Both supply
      power to other entities at sockets or ports, respectively, and are
      often instrumented to measure power per socket or port. Also it
      could be considered to obtain power values for the entity via
      communication with other entities outside of the power distribution
      tree, like for example external databases or even data sheets.</t>
          <t>o  Similar considerations apply to controlling the power supply of an
      entity that often needs direct or indirect communications with
      another entity upstream in the power distribution tree.  Again, a
      PDU and a PoE switch are common examples, if they have the
      capability to switch power on or off at their sockets or ports,
      respectively.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-4">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>inclusion of legacy or non-instrumented devices.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-4">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Energy monitoring across the network, even for devices that lack built-in sensors.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-4">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Indirect control mechanisms.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Integration with external databases or datasheets.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="consideration-of-other-domains-for-obtention-of-end-to-end-metrics">
        <name>Consideration of other domains for obtention of end-to-end metrics</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-5">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>The technologies under the scope of IETF provide the necessary connectivity to other technological domains. For the obtention of metrics end-to-end it would be required to combine or compose the metrics per each of those domains.</t>
          <t>An exemplary case is the one of a network slice service. The concept of network slice was initially defined by 3GPP <xref target="TS23.501"/>, and it has been further extended to the concerns of IETF <xref target="RFC9543"/>.</t>
          <t>In regards energy efficiency, 3GPP defines a number of energy-related key performance indicators (KPI) in <xref target="TS28.554"/>, specifically Energy Efficiency (EE) and Energy Consumption (EC) KPIs. There are KPIs particular for a slice supporting a specific kind of service (e.g., Mobile Broadband or MBB), or generic ones, like Generic Network Slice EE or Network Slice EC. Assuming these as the KPIs of interest, the motivation of this use case is the obtention of the equivalent KPIs at IETF level, that is, for the network slice service as defined in <xref target="RFC9543"/>.</t>
          <t>Note that according to <xref target="TS28.554"/>, the Generic Network Slice EE is the performance of the network slice divided by the Network Slice EC. Same approach can be followed at IETF level. Note that for avoiding double counting the energy at IETF level in the calculation of the end-to-end metric, the 3GPP metric should only consider the efficiency and consumption of the 3GPP-related technologies.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-5">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>cross-domain measurement alignment.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-5">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Cross-domain energy visibility is essential for services spanning multiple infrastructure providers and technologies.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-5">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Avoidance of double accounting.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Metric mapping and transformation.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="dynamic-adjustment-of-network-element-throughput-according-to-traffic-levels-in-wireless-transport-networks">
        <name>Dynamic adjustment of network element throughput according to traffic levels in wireless transport networks</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-6">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>Radio base stations are typically connected to the backbone network by means of fiber or wireless transport (e.g., microwave) technologies. In the specific case of wireless transport, automation frameworks have been defined <xref target="ONF-MW"/><xref target="RFC8432"/><xref target="mWT025"/> for their control and management.</t>
          <t>One of the parameters subject of automated control is the power of the radio links. The relevance of that capability is that the power can be adjusted accordingly to the traffic observed. Wireless transport networks are typically planned to support the maximum traffic capacity in their area of aggregation, that is, the traffic peak. With that input, the number of radio links in the network element and the corresponding power per radio link (for supporting a given modulation and link length in the worst weather conditions) are configured. This is done to avoid any kind of traffic loss in the worst operational situation. However, such operational needs are sporadic, giving room for optimization during normal operational circumstances and/or low traffic periods.</t>
          <t>Power-related parameters are for instance defined in <xref target="RFC8561"/>. Those power parameters can be dynamically configured to adjust the power to the observed traffic levels with some coarse granularity, but pursuing certain degrees of proportionality.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-6">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>This aligns with the GREEN WG goals of enabling dynamic and context-aware energy optimization at the transport layer.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-6">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Wireless links configured for peak traffic are often underutilized, wasting energy. Adjusting power to match demand can substantially reduce consumption.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-6">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Adapt energy consumption to traffic change.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Dynamic energy efficiency control and optimization.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="video-streaming-use-case">
        <name>Video streaming use case</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-7">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>Video streaming is nowadays the major source of traffic observed in ISP networks, in a propotion of 70% or even higher. Over-the-top distribution of streaming traffic is typically done by delivering a unicast flow per end user for the content of its interest.In consequence, during the hours of higher demand, the total traffic in the network is proportional to the concurrence of users consuming the video streaming service. The amount of traffic is also dependent of the resolution of the encoded video (the higher the resolution, the higher the bit rate per video flow), which tends to be higher as long as the users devices support such higher resolutions.</t>
          <t>The consequence of both the growth in the number of flows to be supported simultaneously, and the higher bit rate per flow, is that the nework elements in the path between the source of the video and the user have to be dimensioned accordingly. This implies the continuous upgrade of those network elements in terms of capacity, with the need of deploying high-capacity network elements and components. Apart from the fact that this process is shortening the lifetime of network elements, the need of high capacity interfaces also increase the energy consumption (despite the effort of manufacturers in creating more efficient network element platforms). Note that nowadays there is no actual possibility of activating energy consumption proportionality (in regards the delivered traffic) to such network elements.</t>
          <t>As a mean of slowing down this cycle of continuos renewal, and reduce the need og higher bit rate interfaces / line cards, it seems convenient to explore mechanisms that could reduce the volume of traffic without impacting the user service expectations. Variants of multicast or different service delivery strategies can help to improve the energy efficiency associated to the video streaming service. It should be noted that another front for optimization is the one related to the deployment of cache servers in the network.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-7">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>Video streaming represents a large portion of network traffic. Multicast techniques, adaptive streaming, and strategic caching can reduce traffic duplication and improve energy efficiency.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-7">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Reducing redundant unicast traffic and improving caching strategies reduces backbone and access network energy consumption.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-7">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Support for multicast-aware energy metrics.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Cache server placement optimization.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="wlan-network-energy-saving">
        <name>WLAN Network Energy Saving</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-8">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>In a WLAN network, Access Points(APs) are typically powered by Power over Ethernet (PoE) switches and represent a substantial portion of the energy consumed by edge network devices due to their high density and round-the-clock operation.</t>
          <t>This use case introduces a multi-mode approach for AP energy saving:
The working status of the AP can be break down into 3 modes as follows:
   PoE power-off mode: In this mode, the PoE switch shuts down the port and stops supplying power to the AP. The AP does not consume power at all. When the AP
   wakes up, the port provides power again. In this mode, it usually takes a few minutes for the AP to recover.
   Hibernation mode: Only low power consumption is used to protect key hardware such as the CPU, and other components are shut down.
   Low power consumption mode: Compared with the hibernation mode, the low power consumption mode maintains a certain communication capability. For example, the AP retains only the 2.4 GHz band and disables other radio bands.</t>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>PoE Power-Off Mode: The PoE switch disables the port, completely cutting power to the AP. No energy is consumed, though recovery takes several minutes when power is restored.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Hibernation Mode: The AP powers down most components, preserving minimal CPU functionality to allow faster reactivation.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Low Power Mode: The AP disables some radios (e.g., 5GHz), retaining minimal operation (e.g., 2.4GHz) for reduced but persistent service.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <t>To maintain coverage and service quality, surrounding APs dynamically adjust their transmit power when some APs enter energy-saving states. Energy-saving schedules may be time-based (e.g., during off-hours) or traffic-aware (low utilization periods).</t>
          <t>Grouping APs by location enables coordinated energy-saving plans, minimizing disruption while maximizing cumulative energy reduction.</t>
          <figure anchor="poe-power-off">
            <name>PoE Power Off Mode</name>
            <artwork><![CDATA[
   /---\
  |     +-----+
  | AP  |     |
   \---/      |      +------------+
              |      |            |
              |------+     PoE    |
   /---\      |      |   Switch   |
  |     |     |      +------------+
  | AP  +-----+
   \---/

]]></artwork>
          </figure>
          <figure anchor="low-power-consumption">
            <name>Low Power Consumption Mode</name>
            <artwork><![CDATA[
                 4                         4
 +----------+   \|/        +----------+   \|/
 |          |    |         |          |    |
 |   +----+ |    |         |   +----+ |    |
 |   |5GHz+-+----+         |   |5GHz+-+-X--+
 |   | RF | |    2         |   | RF | |    2
 |   +----+ |   \|/    \   |   +----+ |   \|/
 |   +----+ |    |   ---\  |   +----+ |    |
 |  2.4GHz| |    |       \ |  2.4GHz| |    |
 |   | RF +-+----+       / |   | RF +-+-X--+
 |   +----+ |    2   ---/  |   +----+ |    2
 |   +----+ |   \|/    /   |   +----+ |   \|/
 |  2.4GHz| |    |         |  2.4GHz| |    |
 |   | RF |-+----+         |   | RF +-+----+
 |   +----+ |              |   +----+ |
 +----------+              +----------+

]]></artwork>
          </figure>
          <figure anchor="wireless-resource-management">
            <name>Wireless Resource Management on APs</name>
            <artwork><![CDATA[
     +--+  +--+    +--+
     |AP|--|AP|--- |AP|      ------------------------------
     +--+  +--+   \+--+      Grouping  Recommended
     /               \        Area     Energy Saving Period
  +--+     +--+      +--+    ------------------------------
  |AP|     |AP|      |AP|    XED01-1  01:00:00,06:30:00
  +--+     +--+      +--+
    |                 |      ------------------------------
     +--+          +--+
     |AP|  +--+   /|AP|      XED01-2  01:30:00,06:30:00
     +--+--|AP|--- +--+     --------------------------------
           +--+

]]></artwork>
          </figure>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-8">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>This use case aligns with the GREEN WG's charter by:</t>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Illustrating real-world scenarios where energy efficiency mechanisms (discovery, monitoring, control) apply to IP-managed devices.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Providing a localized but scalable use case that fits into broader energy-aware network management frameworks.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <t>-Addressing interoperability and observability across energy states and reporting mechanisms, including energy mix awareness.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-8">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Given the number of deployed APs in enterprise and campus networks, their continuous operation contributes significantly to energy consumption. Many of these environments experience well-defined periods of inactivity (e.g., nighttime, weekends), during which full AP operation is unnecessary.</t>
          <t>Reducing AP energy consumption during these periods, while maintaining sufficient coverage and quality of service, presents an effective opportunity for energy savings. Applying coordinated power-state transitions across AP groups enables measurable improvements with minimal operational impact.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-8">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <t>To support WLAN Network Energy Saving, the GREEN WG should consider:</t>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Defining power state transition models and standard energy mode nomenclature for APs (e.g., OFF, HIBERNATE, LOW-POWER, ACTIVE).</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Specifying APIs or YANG models for monitoring and controlling AP power modes via PoE switches or WLAN controllers.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Enabling reporting of per-mode energy consumption, transitions over time, and cumulative energy savings.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Ensuring support for scheduled and dynamic (traffic-aware) control policies.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Allowing integration with broader network monitoring frameworks for energy efficiency analysis at the local and network-wide level.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Considering implications for resiliency, coverage trade-offs, and restart delays in power-off scenarios.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <t>Enable measuring and reporting of energy usage through metrics and attributes and allow operators to optimize energy usage.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-9">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>AP nodes as network devices with the largest number consume large amount of energy.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-9">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Energy saving mode switching based on network condition changes</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Allow network devices shutdown to save energy</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Allow working network devices transmit more power to increase the coverage of the entire area</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="fixed-network-energy-saving">
        <name>Fixed Network Energy Saving</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-9">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>In many fixed networks, particularly those at metro or backbone level, traffic patterns follow a predictable tidal cycle - with clearly defined high-traffic and low-traffic periods. These fluctuations provide opportunities for dynamic energy-saving mechanisms. During low-traffic periods, certain network components can be deactivated or put into sleep mode. Additionally, routers equipped with interfaces of varying speeds (e.g., from 1G to 400G) can dynamically adjust interface speeds, deactivate unused ports, or scale down internal resources such as processor cores, chipset clock frequencies, or SerDes lanes, depending on traffic demand.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-9">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>The GREEN working group can contribute by defining standard mechanisms and protocols to:
- Monitor traffic load in a standardized and interoperable manner.
- Communicate energy-saving intents across network elements (e.g., turning off links or reducing interface speeds).
- Signal state transitions (e.g., from active to low-power states) reliably, taking into account the need for fast reactivation during traffic bursts.
- Ensure compatibility with QoS and network availability requirements.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-10">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Network devices at metro or backbone network consume large amount of energy.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-10">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Standardized definitions and telemetry models for identifying tidal traffic patterns and low-utilization windows.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Protocol support for energy-aware dynamic reconfiguration (e.g., speed adjustment, core deactivation).</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Trade-offs between energy savings and network latency/performance.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Mechanisms to synchronize energy-saving decisions across multiple devices (e.g., coordinated interface downshifts).</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Fail-safe or fallback procedures to ensure robustness in case of unexpected traffic surges.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="energy-efficiency-network-management">
        <name>Energy Efficiency Network Management</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-10">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>Modern network operators need comprehensive visibility into the energy consumption and efficiency of their infrastructure. This includes real-time and historical statistics of power usage per device, identification of devices participating in energy-saving modes, differentiation between energy-optimized and legacy devices, and aggregated views of energy trends across the entire network. Such visibility enables more informed decisions about network adjustments and optimizations that align with energy efficiency goals.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-10">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>The GREEN WG has a role in developing interoperable models and mechanisms for:
- Real-time telemetry and historical analysis of energy metrics.
- Mapping energy efficiency indicators to network topology and traffic load.
- Identifying energy-saving capabilities of devices (e.g., support for interface power scaling, sleep modes).
- Integration with existing network management and orchestration systems.
- Encouraging adoption of GREEN-compliant energy observability in vendor equipment.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-11">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>// TODO.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-11">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Standardized YANG models or data formats for energy metrics and efficiency reporting.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Methods to correlate energy usage with traffic load and service demands.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Interfaces for exposing energy capabilities and statuses of devices in a vendor-neutral way.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Security and privacy implications of exposing energy-related telemetry.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Guidelines for presenting energy insights to operators in a way that supports actionable decisions.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="isac-enabled-energy-aware-smart-city-traffic-management">
        <name>ISAC-enabled Energy-Aware Smart City Traffic Management</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-11">
          <name>Use case description</name>
          <t>Integrated Sensing and Communications (ISAC) is emerging as a key
enabler for next-generation wireless networks, integrating sensing
and communication functionalities within a unified system.  By
leveraging the same spectral, hardware, and computational resources,
ISAC enhances network efficiency while enabling new capabilities such
as high-resolution environment perception, object detection, and
situational awareness.  This paradigm shift is particularly relevant
for applications requiring both reliable connectivity and precise
sensing, such as autonomous vehicles, industrial automation, and
smart city deployments.  Given its strategic importance, ISAC has
gained significant traction in standardization efforts.  The ETSI
Industry Specification Group (ISG) on ISAC has been established to
explore technical requirements and use cases, while 3GPP has
initiated discussions on ISAC-related features within its ongoing
research on future 6G systems.  Furthermore, research initiatives
within the IEEE and IETF are investigating how ISAC can be integrated
into network architectures, spectrum management, and protocol design,
making it a critical area of development in the evolution of wireless
networks.</t>
          <t>This use case involves deploying ISAC systems in a smart city to
monitor and optimize vehicles' traffic flows while minimizing energy
consumption of the mobile network.  The system integrates sensing
technologies, such as radar and LIDAR, with communication networks to
detect vehicle density, monitor road conditions, and communicate with
autonomous vehicles or traffic lights.  By using ISAC, the system
minimizes redundant infrastructure (e.g., separate sensors and
communication equipment), thus reducing the overall carbon and energy
footprint.</t>
          <t>On the other hand, such an infrastructure will have to adapt its energy optimization policies to sensing applications: critical functions (e.g., threat detection) must run continuously, while others should activate depending on the context.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-specifics">
          <name>GREEN WG Specifics</name>
          <t>Energy Consumption Monitoring: Each ISAC component (e.g., roadside
units, integrated sensors, and communication transceivers) is capable
of reporting its energy consumption in real time to the centralized
or distributed energy management system.</t>
          <t>Reconfiguration for Energy Efficiency: The system can dynamically
switch between high-resolution sensing modes (e.g., during peak
hours) and low-power modes (e.g., during low traffic periods).  The
network can reconfigure traffic communication paths to prioritize
routes or nodes that consume less power, leveraging energy-efficient
communication protocols.</t>
          <t>Integration of Local and Global Energy Goals: The system can operate
both locally (e.g., turning off specific roadside units in low-
traffic areas) and globally (e.g., modifying traffic patterns across
the city) to achieve defined energy consumption goals.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-12">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ol spacing="normal" type="1"><li>
              <t>Measurement Granularity:</t>
            </li>
          </ol>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Ability to measure energy consumption per ISAC component (e.g., roadside unit, sensor, transceiver).</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Granular reporting per communication link or sensing mode (e.g., high-power radar mode vs. low-power mode).</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <ol spacing="normal" type="1"><li>
              <t>Power Control Mechanisms:</t>
            </li>
          </ol>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Ability to switch components on/off or place them in sleep/standby mode when not in use.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Support for dynamic adjustment of sensing resolution or communication bandwidth to balance energy savings and system performance.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <ol spacing="normal" type="1"><li>
              <t>Reconfiguration and Adaptability:</t>
            </li>
          </ol>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Support for hardware reconfiguration (e.g., adaptive sensing modes, transceiver settings) to optimize energy use.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Mechanisms to steer traffic or adjust network routing based on global or local energy-saving objectives.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <ol spacing="normal" type="1"><li>
              <t>Global Coordination:</t>
            </li>
          </ol>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Capabilities for cross-domain coordination to enable global optimization (e.g., city-wide traffic rerouting or dynamic resource allocation across different regions).</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Ability to aggregate and analyze energy consumption data from all ISAC components to inform high-level decision-making.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
          <ol spacing="normal" type="1"><li>
              <t>Energy-Aware Standards and Protocols:  </t>
              <ul spacing="normal">
                <li>
                  <t>Communication protocols that minimize power usage while maintaining reliability.</t>
                </li>
                <li>
                  <t>Interoperability standards for energy-aware reconfiguration across heterogeneous ISAC components and systems.</t>
                </li>
              </ul>
            </li>
          </ol>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="double-accounting-open-issue">
        <name>Double Accounting Open issue</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-12">
          <name>Use case description</name>
          <t>Energy consumption monitoring often includes metering at both upstream and downstream levels of power distribution. While this can provide granular visibility, it may also lead to double accounting if not carefully managed.</t>
          <t>A common case arises when energy is measured at the input of a Power Delivery Unit (PDU), and individually at each device powered by that PDU (e.g., servers, switches). Since the PDU input already reflects the downstream consumption, summing the per-device values with the PDU input results in redundant reporting.
A similar issue occurs with Power over Ethernet (PoE) infrastructures when a network switch supply power directly to devices. If the total power consumption measured encompasses both the power delivered to the PoE switch and to the powered devices, this again results in double accounting.</t>
          <t>These 2 cases distort energy dashboards and indicators such as Power Usage Effectiveness (PUE).</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-11">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>Unlike most of the WGs, the GREEN WG purpose sums the constraints of data networks and grid/off-grid networks, independantly of the location of the network domain in the architecture (aka edge, core...):
- include the grid network picture in networks operation</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-12">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>// TODO.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-13">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <t>The monitoring must not count twice the power that passthru devices and components monitored, including legacy elements.</t>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="energy-efficiency-under-power-shortage">
        <name>Energy Efficiency Under Power Shortage</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-13">
          <name>Use case description</name>
          <t>This use case focuses on network devices (e.g., routers, switches, access points) that must maintain essential connectivity during power shortages.
Telecom locations use different power backups levels (as example battery, standby generator ...). Devices may have access to one or more backup power sources such as onboard batteries, PoE fallback, or centralized UPS systems. When a power shortage occurs, the network device transitions from grid power to available backup sources and must prioritize operational resilience over typical energy optimization strategies. Unlike behavior in a normally powered state, the focus here is not on minimizing energy consumption per se, but on sustaining essential operation with limited energy and prepare to worse situations and more constrained powered state fallbacks. These behaviors increase the device's ability to operate longer under backup power, ensuring availability of essential services during outages.</t>
          <t>Data networks and grid networks resiliency are closely interleaved during power shortage. It is a race between the speed of the operations to restore the grid network and the availability of mobile connectivity for power grid repair teams because of the impairment of operational visibility and response coordination.</t>
          <t>Network constraints differ in sparse or dense situations but shortage impacts change accordingly. This is becoming crucial and not limited to sparse environments where stable power supply is well known to not be guaranteed: it applies to dense cities' utilities which operations are coupled to the simoultaneous availability of both power and persistent data communication and compute at the edge.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-12">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>Unlike most of the WGs, the GREEN WG purpose sums the constraints of data networks and grid/off-grid networks, independantly of the location of the network domain in the architecture (aka edge, core...):
- Improved networks resiliency by making energy constraints an input into the network's operations.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-13">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>Energy efficiency under power shortage conditions is fundamentally different from routine energy optimization. In this context, energy is a finite and rapidly depleting resource, not just an environmental concern or cost factor:
- Optimize backup power usage for resilience
- Maintain critical networking capabilities during power shortage events
- Maximize operational uptime using fallback power sources</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-14">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>Awareness of backup systems (e.g., batteries, generators).</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Awareness of hierarchical fallback to more constrained powered state.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="energy-efficient-management-of-distributed-ai-training-workloads">
        <name>Energy-Efficient Management of Distributed AI Training Workloads</name>
        <section anchor="use-case-description-14">
          <name>Use Case Description</name>
          <t>Training large AI models requires distributed computing across multiple servers or GPUs. This distributed training generates significant East-West traffic as data is exchanged between nodes. This use case focuses on managing the energy consumption of distributed AI training workloads by optimizing data placement, communication patterns, and compute resource allocation. Strategies include scheduling training jobs to run during periods of lower energy prices, using compression techniques to reduce data transfer volume, and dynamically adjusting the number of active nodes based on training progress. It is also critical to have a cross-domain view of the end to end flow to address power consumption holistically.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-13">
          <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
          <t>This use case contributes to the GREEN WG's goals by addressing the energy efficiency of emerging workloads and exploring the use of dynamic resource allocation to minimize energy consumption. It calls for energy-aware scheduling and optimization techniques.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-14">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
          <t>AI training is a computationally intensive task that consumes a significant amount of energy. Optimizing the energy efficiency of distributed AI training workloads can reduce costs, improve sustainability, and enable more widespread adoption of AI technologies. There is an impact not only for the network consumption, rather than the compute consumption.</t>
        </section>
        <section anchor="requirements-for-green-wg-15">
          <name>Requirements for GREEN WG</name>
          <ul spacing="normal">
            <li>
              <t>East-West Traffic Monitoring: Standardized mechanisms for monitoring the volume, type, and characteristics of East-West traffic.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Workload Characterization: Standardized methods for characterizing the energy consumption profile of AI training workloads.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Energy-Aware Scheduling: APIs for scheduling training jobs based on energy prices, grid conditions, and other energy-related factors.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Data Compression and Optimization: Techniques for reducing the volume of data transferred during distributed training.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Dynamic Resource Allocation: Mechanisms for dynamically adjusting the number of active nodes based on training progress and energy availability.</t>
            </li>
            <li>
              <t>Resource co-location, so the data used for processing can be as close as possible to the data crunching machines.</t>
            </li>
          </ul>
        </section>
      </section>
    </section>
    <section anchor="security-considerations">
      <name>Security Considerations</name>
      <t>Energy efficiency management comes with numerous security considerations :</t>
      <t>Controlling Power State and power supply of entities are considered
   highly sensitive actions, since they can significantly affect the
   operation of directly and indirectly connected devices.  Therefore,
   all control actions must be
   sufficiently protected through authentication, authorization, and
   integrity protection mechanisms.</t>
      <t>Entities that are not sufficiently secure to operate directly on the
   public Internet do exist and can be a significant cause of risk, for
   example, if the remote control functions can be exercised on those devices from anywhere on the Internet.</t>
      <t>The monitoring of energy-related quantities of an entity as addressed
   can be used to derive more information than
   just the received and provided energy; therefore, monitored data
   requires protection.  This protection includes authentication and
   authorization of entities requesting access to monitored data as well
   as confidentiality protection during transmission of monitored data.
   Privacy of stored data in an entity must be taken into account.
   Monitored data may be used as input to control, accounting, and other
   actions, so integrity of transmitted information and authentication
   of the origin may be needed.</t>
    </section>
    <section anchor="iana-considerations">
      <name>IANA Considerations</name>
      <t>This document has no IANA actions.</t>
    </section>
    <section anchor="acknowledgments">
      <name>Acknowledgments</name>
      <t>The contribution of Luis M. Contreras to this document has been supported by the Smart Networks and Services Joint Undertaking (SNS JU) under the European Union's Horizon Europe research and innovation projects 6Green (Grant Agreement no. 101096925) and Exigence (Grant Agreement no. 101139120).</t>
    </section>
    <section anchor="use-cases-living-list">
      <name>Use Cases Living List</name>
      <t>Consider 5g vs network slicing: 3GPP spec describing energy efficiency KPIs. 3GPP TS 28.554. Reference:https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/rfc9543/
Connectivity from radio side (trying to control the traffic/related work to CCAMP)
Marisol to add one use case: drift from data specifications... (somehow link to the above)
Energy Metric in E2E view</t>
    </section>
    <section anchor="references">
      <name>References</name>
      <section anchor="normative-references">
        <name>Normative References</name>
        <t>[IEC.61850-7-4]
              International Electrotechnical Commission, "Communication
              networks and systems for power utility automation --
              Part 7-4: Basic communication structure -- Compatible
              logical node classes and data object classes", March 2010.</t>
        <t>[IEC.62053-21]
              International Electrotechnical Commission, "Electricity
              metering equipment (a.c.) -- Particular requirements --
              Part 21: Static meters for active energy (classes 1
              and 2)", January 2003.</t>
        <t>[IEC.62053-22]
              International Electrotechnical Commission, "Electricity
              metering equipment (a.c.) -- Particular requirements --
              Part 22: Static meters for active energy (classes 0,2 S
              and 0,5 S)", January 2003.</t>
        <t>[ATIS-0600015.03.2013]
              ATIS, "ATIS-0600015.03.2013: Energy Efficiency for
              Telecommunication Equipment: Methodology for Measurement
              and Reporting for Router and Ethernet Switch Products",
              2013.</t>
      </section>
      <section anchor="informative-references">
        <name>Informative References</name>
        <t>[IEC.60050] International Electrotechnical Commission, "Electropedia:
   The World's Online Electrotechnical Vocabulary", 2013,
   <eref target="http://www.electropedia.org/iev/iev.nsf/welcome?openform">http://www.electropedia.org/iev/iev.nsf/welcome?openform</eref>.</t>
      </section>
    </section>
    <section anchor="appendix-i-template-preparation">
      <name>Appendix I: Template preparation</name>
      <t>This appendix should be removed when the template will be stable.</t>
      <t>It is based on the example from https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/rfc9450/.</t>
      <section anchor="use-case-description-15">
        <name>Use Case Description</name>
        <t>General description of the use case.</t>
      </section>
      <section anchor="green-wg-charter-specifics-14">
        <name>GREEN WG Charter Specifics</name>
        <t>(if there are no GREEN specific aspects, then it is not a UC to be documented)
For example, the use case involves components that can report on energy consumption and that might be reconfigured (on a local or global scale) to operate based on energy goals/limitations.</t>
        <section anchor="the-need-for-energy-efficiency-15">
          <name>The Need for Energy Efficiency</name>
        </section>
      </section>
      <section anchor="requirements-for-green">
        <name>Requirements for GREEN</name>
        <t>Examples (can be split into different categories to facilitate a summary at the end of the document):</t>
        <ul spacing="normal">
          <li>
            <t>Granularity of measurements should be per component, per line, per port.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t>Ability to switch on/off, put on sleep mode' components.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t>Ability to reconfigure hardware mode based on power savings (e.g., reduce reliability or speed).</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t>Ability to operate globally (not constrained to just one device) based on power savings/goals
(e.g., steer traffic using a different path that consumes less energy).</t>
          </li>
        </ul>
        <figure anchor="green-framework">
          <name>Framework discussed during the BoF</name>
          <artwork><![CDATA[
(a)              (b)              (c)
Inventory        Monitor       +- DataSheets/DataBase and/or via API
Of identity      Energy        |  Metadata and other device/component
and Capability   Efficiency    |  /network related information:
     ^               ^         |
     |               |         |  .Power/Energy related metrics
     |               |         |  .information
     |               |         |  .origin of Energy Mix
     |               |         |  .carbon aware based on location
     |               |         |
     |               |         |
     |               |         |
     |               |         v
+--------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                   *                                                |
|     (2) controller   (collection, compute and aggregate?)          |
|                                                                    |
+--------------------------------------------------------------------+
             ^              ^                   ^ |
  (d)        |  (e)         |  (f)              | |(g)
  Inventory  |  Monitor     |  GREEN WG:        | |GREEN WG: Control
  Capability |  Traffic     |  Monitor power    | |(Energy saving
             |  & power     |  Proportion,      | |Functionality
             |  consumption |  Energy efficiency| |Localized mgmt/
             |              |  ratio, etc)      | |network wide mgmt)
             |              |                   | |
             |              |                   | |
             |              |                   | v
+--------------------------------------------------------------------+
|                                            *                       |
|                  (1) Device/Component Level                        |
|                                                                    |
| +---------+  +-----------+  +----------------+  +----------------+ |
| | (I)     |  | (II)      |  | (III)          |  | (IV)           | |
| | Network |  | Device    |  | Legacy Network |  | 'Attached'(PoE | |
| | Device  |  | Component |  | Device         |  | kind) Device   | |
| |         |  |           |  |                |  |                | |
| +---------+  +-----------+  +----------------+  +----------------+ |
+--------------------------------------------------------------------+

(*) Energy Efficiency Management Function is implemented inside the
device or in a controller

]]></artwork>
        </figure>
        <t>The main elements in the framework are as follows:</t>
        <t>(a),(d) Discovery and Inventory</t>
        <t>(b),(c) GREEN Metrics</t>
        <t>(b),(f) Monitor energy efficiency</t>
        <t>(e) Monitor power consumption and traffic (IPPM WG throughput, traffic load, etc)</t>
        <t>(g) Control Energy Saving</t>
      </section>
    </section>
    <section anchor="appendix-ii-necessity-and-impact-of-a-framework-for-energy-efficiency-management">
      <name>Appendix II: Necessity and Impact of a Framework for Energy Efficiency Management</name>
      <t>This appendix outlines the necessity of defining a framework for energy efficiency management within the GREEN Working Group's current phase. Establishing a framework now is crucial for standardizing processes, optimizing energy usage, and ensuring interoperability across network devices. Immediate action enables the industry to achieve cost savings, meet regulatory requirements, and maintain competitiveness. By utilizing insights from existing use cases, the framework can deliver actionable metrics and support ongoing innovation, positioning the industry to effectively manage future energy challenges.</t>
      <section anchor="framework-necessity">
        <name>Framework Necessity</name>
        <t>Analyzing use cases such as the "Incremental Application of the GREEN Framework" reveals the critical need for a structured approach to transitioning network devices towards energy-efficient operations. The framework is essential for:</t>
        <ul spacing="normal">
          <li>
            <t><strong>Standardization</strong>: Ensuring consistent practices across different devices and network segments to facilitate interoperability.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Efficient Energy Management</strong>: Providing guidelines to identify inefficiencies and implement improvements.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Scalability</strong>: Offering solutions that accommodate growing network demands and complexity.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Cost Reduction</strong>: Optimizing energy usage to lower operational costs and extend equipment lifecycles.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Competitiveness</strong>: Enabling organizations to maintain a competitive edge through enhanced sustainability.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Environmental Impact</strong>: Supporting broader sustainability initiatives by reducing carbon footprints.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Simplified Implementation</strong>: Streamlining the deployment of energy-efficient measures to minimize service disruptions.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Security</strong>: Protecting sensitive operations related to power states and consumption.</t>
          </li>
        </ul>
      </section>
      <section anchor="use-cases-calling-for-a-framework">
        <name>Use Cases Calling for a Framework</name>
        <t>Multiple use cases underscore the need for a framework, including:</t>
        <ul spacing="normal">
          <li>
            <t><strong>Incremental Application of the GREEN Framework</strong></t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Selective Reduction of Energy Consumption in Network Parts</strong></t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Real-time Energy Metering of Virtualized or Cloud-native Network Functions</strong></t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Indirect Energy Monitoring and Control</strong></t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Consideration of Other Domains for Obtention of End-to-End Metrics</strong></t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Dynamic Adjustment of Network Element Throughput</strong></t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Video Streaming Use Case</strong></t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>WLAN Network Energy Saving</strong></t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Fixed Network Energy Saving</strong></t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Energy Efficiency Network Management</strong></t>
          </li>
        </ul>
        <t>These use cases highlight diverse aspects of energy management that require a cohesive framework for effective implementation.</t>
      </section>
      <section anchor="impact-on-energy-metrics">
        <name>Impact on Energy Metrics</name>
        <t>The framework will significantly enhance the creation of energy metrics with actionable insights by:</t>
        <ul spacing="normal">
          <li>
            <t><strong>Standardizing Metrics</strong>: Establishing consistent measurement protocols for energy consumption and efficiency.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Enhancing Data Collection</strong>: Facilitating comprehensive monitoring and data aggregation across devices.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Supporting Real-time Monitoring</strong>: Enabling dynamic tracking and immediate optimization of energy usage.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Integration Across Devices</strong>: Ensuring interoperability for network-wide data analysis.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Providing Actionable Insights</strong>: Translating raw data into meaningful information for decision-making.</t>
          </li>
        </ul>
      </section>
      <section anchor="current-device-readiness">
        <name>Current Device Readiness</name>
        <t>While many modern networking devices have basic energy monitoring capabilities, these are often proprietary. The framework will define requirements to enhance these capabilities, enabling standardized metric production and meaningful data contributions for energy management goals.</t>
      </section>
      <section anchor="why-now">
        <name>Why Now?</name>
        <t>The decision to define the framework now, rather than later, is driven by:</t>
        <ul spacing="normal">
          <li>
            <t><strong>Immediate Benefits</strong>: Start realizing cost savings, reduced carbon footprints, and improved efficiencies.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Rapid Technological Advancements</strong>: Aligning the framework with current technologies to prevent obsolescence.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Increasing Energy Demands</strong>: Mitigating the impact of growing energy consumption on costs and sustainability.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Regulatory Pressure</strong>: Preparing for compliance with existing and anticipated sustainability regulations.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Competitive Advantage</strong>: Positioning organizations as leaders in sustainability and innovation.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Foundational Work Ready</strong>: Building on the use cases and requirements established in Phase I.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Proactive Risk Management</strong>: Minimizing risks associated with energy costs and environmental factors.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Facilitate Future Innovations</strong>: Creating a platform for continuous improvements and adaptations.</t>
          </li>
          <li>
            <t><strong>Stakeholder Engagement</strong>: Ensuring diverse perspectives are reflected for broader adoption.</t>
          </li>
        </ul>
        <t>In conclusion, establishing the framework for energy efficiency management now is strategic and timely, leveraging the current momentum of use cases and requirements to drive meaningful progress in energy efficiency management. Delaying its development could result in missed opportunities for immediate benefits, increased costs, and challenges in adapting to future technological and regulatory landscapes.</t>
      </section>
    </section>
  </middle>
  <back>
    <references anchor="sec-informative-references">
      <name>Informative References</name>
      <reference anchor="legacy-path" target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-stephan-legacy-path-eco-design">
        <front>
          <title>Requirements for Energy Efficiency Management</title>
          <author>
            <organization/>
          </author>
          <date year="2024" month="July" day="21"/>
        </front>
      </reference>
      <reference anchor="TS23.501">
        <front>
          <title>3GPP TS 23.501, System architecture for the 5G System (5GS), 17.6.0.</title>
          <author>
            <organization/>
          </author>
          <date year="2022" month="September" day="22"/>
        </front>
      </reference>
      <reference anchor="TS28.554">
        <front>
          <title>3GPP TS 28.554, Management and orchestration; 5G end to end Key Performance Indicators (KPI), 17.15.0.</title>
          <author>
            <organization/>
          </author>
          <date year="2024" month="September" day="25"/>
        </front>
      </reference>
      <reference anchor="ONF-MW">
        <front>
          <title>ONF TR-532, Microwave Information Model, version 2.0.</title>
          <author>
            <organization/>
          </author>
          <date year="2024" month="January" day="31"/>
        </front>
      </reference>
      <reference anchor="mWT025">
        <front>
          <title>ETSI GR mWT 025, Wireless Backhaul Network and Services Automation: SDN SBI YANG models, V1.1.1.</title>
          <author>
            <organization/>
          </author>
          <date year="2021" month="March" day="31"/>
        </front>
      </reference>
      <reference anchor="GREEN_NGNM" target="https://www.ngmn.org/publications/metering-in-virtualised-ran-infrastructure.html">
        <front>
          <title>NGMN Alliance, GREEN FUTURE NETWORKS: METERING IN VIRTUALISED RAN INFRASTRUCTURE</title>
          <author>
            <organization/>
          </author>
          <date>n.d.</date>
        </front>
      </reference>
      <reference anchor="RFC9543">
        <front>
          <title>A Framework for Network Slices in Networks Built from IETF Technologies</title>
          <author fullname="A. Farrel" initials="A." role="editor" surname="Farrel"/>
          <author fullname="J. Drake" initials="J." role="editor" surname="Drake"/>
          <author fullname="R. Rokui" initials="R." surname="Rokui"/>
          <author fullname="S. Homma" initials="S." surname="Homma"/>
          <author fullname="K. Makhijani" initials="K." surname="Makhijani"/>
          <author fullname="L. Contreras" initials="L." surname="Contreras"/>
          <author fullname="J. Tantsura" initials="J." surname="Tantsura"/>
          <date month="March" year="2024"/>
          <abstract>
            <t>This document describes network slicing in the context of networks built from IETF technologies. It defines the term "IETF Network Slice" to describe this type of network slice and establishes the general principles of network slicing in the IETF context.</t>
            <t>The document discusses the general framework for requesting and operating IETF Network Slices, the characteristics of an IETF Network Slice, the necessary system components and interfaces, and the mapping of abstract requests to more specific technologies. The document also discusses related considerations with monitoring and security.</t>
            <t>This document also provides definitions of related terms to enable consistent usage in other IETF documents that describe or use aspects of IETF Network Slices.</t>
          </abstract>
        </front>
        <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="9543"/>
        <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC9543"/>
      </reference>
      <reference anchor="RFC8432">
        <front>
          <title>A Framework for Management and Control of Microwave and Millimeter Wave Interface Parameters</title>
          <author fullname="J. Ahlberg" initials="J." role="editor" surname="Ahlberg"/>
          <author fullname="M. Ye" initials="M." role="editor" surname="Ye"/>
          <author fullname="X. Li" initials="X." surname="Li"/>
          <author fullname="LM. Contreras" initials="LM." surname="Contreras"/>
          <author fullname="CJ. Bernardos" initials="CJ." surname="Bernardos"/>
          <date month="October" year="2018"/>
          <abstract>
            <t>The unification of control and management of microwave radio link interfaces is a precondition for seamless multi-layer networking and automated network provisioning and operation.</t>
            <t>This document describes the required characteristics and use cases for control and management of radio link interface parameters using a YANG data model.</t>
            <t>The purpose is to create a framework to identify the necessary information elements and define a YANG data model for control and management of the radio link interfaces in a microwave node. Some parts of the resulting model may be generic and could also be used by other technologies, e.g., Ethernet technology.</t>
          </abstract>
        </front>
        <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="8432"/>
        <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC8432"/>
      </reference>
      <reference anchor="RFC8561">
        <front>
          <title>A YANG Data Model for Microwave Radio Link</title>
          <author fullname="J. Ahlberg" initials="J." surname="Ahlberg"/>
          <author fullname="M. Ye" initials="M." surname="Ye"/>
          <author fullname="X. Li" initials="X." surname="Li"/>
          <author fullname="D. Spreafico" initials="D." surname="Spreafico"/>
          <author fullname="M. Vaupotic" initials="M." surname="Vaupotic"/>
          <date month="June" year="2019"/>
          <abstract>
            <t>This document defines a YANG data model for control and management of radio link interfaces and their connectivity to packet (typically Ethernet) interfaces in a microwave/millimeter wave node. The data nodes for management of the interface protection functionality is broken out into a separate and generic YANG data model in order to make it available for other interface types as well.</t>
          </abstract>
        </front>
        <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="8561"/>
        <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC8561"/>
      </reference>
    </references>
  </back>
  <!-- ##markdown-source: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-->

</rfc>
